I was working on a program that takes an input, and solves it. I used Sympy. I assumed because this works:
from sympy import symbols, Eq, solve
x, y = symbols("x y")
eq1 = Eq(5 + x)
eq2 = Eq(5 + y)
sol = solve((eq1, eq2),(x, y))
print(sol)
Gives the result:
{x: -5, y: -5}
This should work too, because I'm splitting it, formatting the code correctly, and it has the inputs of "a" and "z":
from sympy import symbols, Eq, solve
Input = input("Please give the two variables the names 'a' and 'z': ").replace("x", "*").replace("^", "**").upper().split(" = ")
a, z = symbols("a z")
othersol = solve((Input[0], Input[1]),(a, z))
print(othersol)
Though, when given the input:
5 + a = 5 + z
It gives the result:
[]
I want to know why it is not solving, why it doesn't work, and how I can make a program that takes an input and solves the equation given. If I need to, I will even switch my Python Library. If not, can you give the code that takes an input, and solves that equation?
Can anybody do that?
Thanks.
You see what is wrong in here when you compare what you are giving as first parameter to your solve function.
In your working code you do like this:
eq1 = Eq(5 + x)
eq2 = Eq(5 + y)
sol = solve((eq1, eq2),(x, y))
First parameter is two Eq objects.
Let's see what is going on in your non-working code.
>>> Input = input("Please give the two variables the names 'a' and 'z': ").replace("x", "*").replace("^", "**").upper().split(" = ")
Please give the two variables the names 'a' and 'z': a+1 = zx3
>>> Input
['A+1', 'Z*3']
>>> type(Input[0])
<class 'str'>
>>> solve((Input[0], Input[1]),(a, z))
[]
There first parameter is tuple of two strings.
So you'd need to parse your Input-strings to Eq objects. Then you'd have working code. It may be challenging task though if you want to allow your user enter freetext input. Input in polish notation or some other more strcutured way would be much easier to parse.
--- EDIT ----
With exec it could be something like this. I Added a function to secure input a bit. This will fail if there is unknown characters in input.
from sympy import symbols, Eq, solve
A, Z = symbols("A Z")
def secure_input(inputstring):
known_symbols = {" ","A","Z","+","*","**","-"}
if not all([x in known_symbols or x.isdigit() for x in inputstring]):
raise Exception("Illegal strings in input %s"%inputstring)
return inputstring
Input = input("Please give the two variables the names 'a' and 'z': ").replace("x", "*").replace("^", "**").upper().split(" = ")
i1 = secure_input(Input[0])
i2 = secure_input(Input[1])
exec("eq1 = Eq(%s)" % i1)
exec("eq2 = Eq(%s)" % i2)
solve((eq1,eq2),(A, Z))
Also, you used lower-case variable names but you said upper() for your input string. I changed that as well, now the code should work.
from sympy import symbols, Eq, solve
A, Z = symbols("A Z")
def secure_input(inputstring):
known_symbols = {" ","A","Z","+","*","**","-"}
if not all([x in known_symbols or x.isdigit() for x in inputstring]):
raise Exception("Illegal strings in input %s"%inputstring)
return inputstring
Input = input("Please give the two variables the names 'a' and 'z': ").replace("x", "*").replace("^", "**").upper().split(" = ")
i1 = secure_input(Input[0])
i2 = secure_input(Input[1])
exec("eq1 = Eq(%s)" % i1)
exec("eq2 = Eq(%s)" % i2)
A = solve((eq1,eq2),A)
Z = solve((eq1,eq2),Z)
print(str(A).replace("{","").replace("}", ""))
print(str(Z).replace("{","").replace("}", ""))
Related
When I use "x" and "z" as symbols, I have no problem with this code:
from sympy import *
x, z = symbols('x z')
y = -6*x**2 + 2*x*z**0.5 + 50*x - z
solve((diff(y, x), diff(y, z)))
y.subs({x: 5, z: 25})
But when I use "q" and "a", solve does not give me any solution.
q, a = symbols('q a')
y = -6*q**2 + 2*q*a**0.5 + 50*q - a
solve((diff(y, q), diff(y, a)))
y.subs({q: 5, a: 25})
As you can see I use "subs" to check that there is no typo in the objective function.
UPDATE: I used "Symbol" to set each variable individually, but again using "q" and "a" does not work.
# This works
x = Symbol('x')
z = Symbol('z')
y = -6*x**2 + 2*x*z**0.5 + 50*x - z
solve((diff(y, x), diff(y, z)))
# This does not work
q = Symbol('q')
a = Symbol('a')
y = -6*q**2 + 2*q*a**0.5 + 50*q-a
solve((diff(y, q), diff(y, a)))
Thank you.
Got it!
It all depends on an alphabetic order of your variables.
If you substitute x for z and z for x in your first example it will also stop working.
Internally solve sends the expression to the function _solve in sympy.solvers which then tries to solve your equation and fails many times.
Finally as a last effort what it does is it tries to solve -sqrt(a) + q or x - sqrt(z) by picking symbols from it through an internal function _ok_syms, with an argument that sorts those alphabetically (even without this argument it still would, but if wrapped with reversed it magically makes your examples works in the exactly opposite way).
And so it does solve x - sqrt(z) as x: sqrt(z) and -sqrt(a) + q as a: q**2.
While in the first case it ends up with an easily solvable 50 - 10*sqrt(z), in the second case it is lost on -12*q + 2*sqrt(q**2) + 50 as it is not able to simplify sqrt(q**2).
source:
a lot of testing on:
https://github.com/sympy/sympy/blob/master/sympy/solvers/solvers.py
I'm trying to make some program which involves typing formulas in input by a user.
My code for now looks like so:
import numpy as np
n = int(input('Dim = '))
g = np.zeros((n, n))
for a in range(0, n):
print('Define the metric. \n g_', a, a,'=')
metric_component = 'lambda x, y: ' + str(input())
g[a, a] = eval(metric_component)
print(g)
I tried to search for answers but those i found didn't work. eval() function gives me error there: float() argument must be a string or a number, not 'function': sympify() gives basically the same "can't convert expression to float"
Also i want to work on those constants not their numeric values, so i'm interesting to keep them through all program and have the final output expressed by them. Is it even possible?
input() will return a string
>>> type(input()) # I type 1
1
<class 'str'>
So if you are expecting numeric input from the user and it can be non-integer, then just wrap the input with float.
import numpy as np
n = int(input('Dim = '))
g = np.zeros((n, n))
for a in range(0, n):
print('Define the metric. \n g_', a, a,'=')
g[a, a] = float(input())
print(g)
It's hard to tell what you want to be able to interpret from the user. If the user is going to give some expression of x and y and you are going to replace both those values with a you would either have to build a lambda that could be evaluated or do a substitution into a sympified expression:
>>> eval('(lambda x,y:'+'x + 2*y'+')(%s,%s)'%(a,a))
3*a
>>> sympify('x+2*y').subs(dict(x=a,y=a))
3*a
If you want the user to input expressions and then do something to them later, SymPy is ideally suited for this. Here, the user is prompted to fill items in a list and then those items are differentiated wrt x. It's just a toy example:
>>> from sympy import S # shortcut for sympify
>>> from sympy.abc import x
>>> [S(input('?')) for i in range(2)]
?R**2
?R**2*sin(x)**2
[R**2, R**2*sin(x)**2]
>>> [i.diff(x) for i in _]
[0, 2*R**2*sin(x)*cos(x)]
I'm currently doing a maths course where my aim is to understand the concepts and process rather than crunch through problem sets as fast as possible. When solving equations, I'd like to be able to poke at them myself rather than have them solved for me.
Let's say we have the very simple equation z + 1 = 4- if I were to solve this myself, I would obviously subtract 1 from both sides, but I can't figure out if sympy provides a simple way to do this. At the moment the best solution I can come up with is:
from sympy import *
z = symbols('z')
eq1 = Eq(z + 1, 4)
Eq(eq1.lhs - 1, eq1.rhs - 1)
# Output:
# z == 3
Where the more obvious expression eq1 - 1 only subtracts from the left-hand side. How can I use sympy to work through equalities step-by-step like this (i.e. without getting the solve() method to just given me the answer)? Any pointers to the manipulations that are actually possible with sympy equalities would be appreciated.
There is a "do" method and discussion at https://github.com/sympy/sympy/issues/5031#issuecomment-36996878 that would allow you to "do" operations to both sides of an Equality. It's not been accepted as an addition to SymPy but it is a simple add-on that you can use. It is pasted here for convenience:
def do(self, e, i=None, doit=False):
"""Return a new Eq using function given or a model
model expression in which a variable represents each
side of the expression.
Examples
========
>>> from sympy import Eq
>>> from sympy.abc import i, x, y, z
>>> eq = Eq(x, y)
When the argument passed is an expression with one
free symbol that symbol is used to indicate a "side"
in the Eq and an Eq will be returned with the sides
from self replaced in that expression. For example, to
add 2 to both sides:
>>> eq.do(i + 2)
Eq(x + 2, y + 2)
To add x to both sides:
>>> eq.do(i + x)
Eq(2*x, x + y)
In the preceding it was actually ambiguous whether x or i
was to be added but the rule is that any symbol that are
already in the expression are not to be interpreted as the
dummy variable. If we try to add z to each side, however, an
error is raised because now it is unclear whether i or z is being
added:
>>> eq.do(i + z)
Traceback (most recent call last):
...
ValueError: not sure what symbol is being used to represent a side
The ambiguity must be resolved by indicating with another parameter
which is the dummy variable representing a side:
>>> eq.do(i + z, i)
Eq(x + z, y + z)
Alternatively, if only one Dummy symbol appears in the expression then
it will be automatically used to represent a side of the Eq.
>>> eq.do(2*Dummy() + z)
Eq(2*x + z, 2*y + z)
Operations like differentiation must be passed as a
lambda:
>>> Eq(x, y).do(lambda i: i.diff(x))
Eq(1, 0)
Because doit=False by default, the result is not evaluated. to
evaluate it, either use the doit method or pass doit=True.
>>> _.doit == Eq(x, y).do(lambda i: i.diff(x), doit=True)
True
"""
if not isinstance(e, (FunctionClass, Lambda, type(lambda:1))):
e = S(e)
imaybe = e.free_symbols - self.free_symbols
if not imaybe:
raise ValueError('expecting a symbol')
if imaybe and i and i not in imaybe:
raise ValueError('indicated i not in given expression')
if len(imaybe) != 1 and not i:
d = [i for i in imaybe if isinstance(i, Dummy)]
if len(d) != 1:
raise ValueError(
'not sure what symbol is being used to represent a side')
i = set(d)
else:
i = imaybe
i = i.pop()
f = lambda side: e.subs(i, side)
else:
f = e
return self.func(*[f(side) for side in self.args], evaluate=doit)
from sympy.core.relational import Equality
Equality.do = do
I have a number of symbolic expressions in sympy, and I may come to realize that one of the coefficients is zero. I would think, perhaps because I am used to mathematica, that the following makes sense:
from sympy import Symbol
x = Symbol('x')
y = Symbol('y')
f = x + y
x = 0
f
Surprisingly, what is returned is x + y. Is there any way, aside from explicitly calling "subs" on every equation, for f to return just y?
I think subs is the only way to do this. It looks like a sympy expression is something unto itself. It does not reference the pieces that made it up. That is f only has the expression x+y, but doesn't know it has any link back to the python objects x and y. Consider the code below:
from sympy import Symbol
x = Symbol('x')
y = Symbol('y')
z = Symbol('z')
f1 = x + y
f2 = z + f1
f1 = f1.subs(x,0)
print(f1)
print(f2)
The output from this is
y
x + y + z
So even though f1 has changed f2 hasn't. To my knowledge subs is the only way to get done what you want.
I don't think there is a way to do that automatically (or at least no without modifying SymPy).
The following question from SymPy's FAQ explains why:
Why doesn't changing one variable change another that depends it?
The short answer is "because it doesn't depend on it." :-) Even though
you are working with equations, you are still working with Python
objects. The equations you are typing use the values present at the
time of creation to "fill in" values, just like regular python
definitions. They are not altered by changes made afterwards. Consider
the following:
>>> a = Symbol('a') # create an object with name 'a' for variable a to point to
>>> b = a + 1; b # create another object that refers to what 'a' refers to
a + 1
>>> a = 4; a # a now points to the literal integer 4, not Symbol('a')
4
>>> b # but b is still pointing at Symbol('a')
a + 1
Changing quantity a does not change b; you are not working with a set
of simultaneous equations. It might be helpful to remember that the
string that gets printed when you print a variable refering to a sympy
object is the string that was give to it when it was created; that
string does not have to be the same as the variable that you assign it
to:
>>> r, t, d = symbols('rate time short_life')
>>> d = r*t; d
rate*time
>>> r=80; t=2; d # we haven't changed d, only r and t
rate*time
>>> d=r*t; d # now d is using the current values of r and t
160
Maybe this is not what you're looking for (as it was already explained by others), but this is my solution to substitute several values at once.
def GlobalSubs(exprNames, varNames, values=[]):
if ( len(values) == 0 ): # Get the values from the
for varName in varNames: # variables when not defined
values.append( eval(varName) ) # as argument.
# End for.
# End if.
for exprName in exprNames: # Create a temp copy
expr = eval(exprName) # of each expression
for i in range(len(varNames)): # and substitute
expr = expr.subs(varNames[i], values[i]) # each variable.
# End for.
yield expr # Return each expression.
# End for.
It works even for matrices!
>>> x, y, h, k = symbols('x, y, h, k')
>>> A = Matrix([[ x, -h],
... [ h, x]])
>>> B = Matrix([[ y, k],
... [-k, y]])
>>> x = 2; y = 4; h = 1; k = 3
>>> A, B = GlobalSubs(['A', 'B'], ['x', 'h', 'y', 'k'])
>>> A
Matrix([
[2, -1],
[1, 2]])
>>> B
Matrix([
[ 4, 3],
[-3, 4]])
But don't try to make a module with this. It won't work. This will only work when the expressions, the variables and the function are defined into the same file, so everything is global for the function and it can access them.
Given a simple equation such as:
x = y + z
You can get the third variable if you bind the other two (ie: y = x - z and z = x - y). A straightforward way to put this in code:
def solve(args):
if 'x' not in args:
return args['y'] + args['z']
elif 'z' not in args:
return args['x'] - args['y']
elif 'y' not in args:
return args['x'] - args['z']
else:
raise SomeError
I obviously can take an equation, parse it and simplify it to achieve the same effect.
But I believe in doing so I would be re-inventing the wheel. So where's my ready-made wheel?
Consider using Sympy. It includes various tools to solve equations and a lot more.
The following is an excerpt from the docs:
>>> from sympy import I, solve
>>> from sympy.abc import x, y
>>> solve(x**4-1, x)
[1, -1, -I, I]